Showing posts with label blue. Show all posts
Showing posts with label blue. Show all posts

Thursday, November 26, 2009

Bad Deck Baz Presents Blisters On Your Fingers!

Hello and welcome to the second of the Bad Deck Baz posts. Last time, we looked at IT'S A TRAP!, which I piloted to a 1-3 record: not too bad given the deck. Let's see if I can repeat myself with this deck: Blisters on Your Fingers.


A “Bad Deck Baz” Deck

14 Island
2 Swamp
4 Jwar Isle Refuge
4 Drowned Catacomb

4 Alluring Siren
4 Wall of Frost
4 Sphinx Ambassador
4 Cosi's Trickster
4 Gomazoa

2 Quest for Ancient Secrets
3 Sadistic Sacrament
4 Telemin Performance
4 Polymorph
3 Haunting Echoes

Sideboard 

1 Platinum Angel
3 Marsh Casualties
4 Kathari Remnant
3 Deny Reality
4 Flashfreeze


Blisters On Your Fingers is a shuffling-based deck, with cards like Polymorph, Haunting Echoes, Gomozoa, and Cosi's Trickster. The alternate aim is to win with a Sphinx Ambassador.

The deck also has a library exiling theme, where you get rid of the opponent's bad creatures to Telemin them, or their good creatures to Polymorph them.

Let's get to testing!

Round 1: Blisters on Creatureless Control's fingers!

I don't really know how to classify this control deck, but as a creatureless deck I was hoping for a random Telemin win. 

Game 1 I play Alluring Siren and Gomozoa. I take a few points off him before he casts a Day of Judgment. I drop Sphinx Ambassador and he retaliates with Martial Coup. I drop another one. Next turn I swing. I reveal no creatures, but plenty of planeswalkers and controllish cards. He's on 8 life.

He uses Vengeant to keep my Sphinx tapped. I try to resist, but he gets me to 10, then a combination Ajani Helix and Earthquake for 7 clinches it for him.

0-1

Round 2: Blisters on WBR Midrange's Fingers!

Game 1 I play two Tricksters. He cracks an Armillary Sphere, and I start swinging. He drops Day of Judgment. He then drops Blightning, Sorin, and Siege-Gang, and slaughters me. At 1 life I drop a Polymorph to see a bit more of his deck.

Game 2 is rather anti-climactic. I get mana-screwed, he gets a Turn 5 Siege-Gang Commander. I never offer any real resistance.

0-2

Round 3: Blisters on White Weenie's Fingers!

I drop Trickster, he drops Knight of the White Orchid. I drop Gomozoa, he Paths it. He plays Conqueror's Pledge and Elspeth. He gets a quick win.

Game 2 he plays: Kazandu Blademaster, Knight of the White Orchid, Veteran Swordsmith. He then gets Behemoth Sledge and Elspeth. I Polymorph the Blademaster into an Armorsmith, and Telemin into a Captain of the Watch. I'm on 8 life, but he equips the Sledge to his Swordsmith, pumps it with Elspeth, and swings for 8 in the air :(

0-3

Round 4: Blisters on Jacerator's Fingers!

I drop two Cosi's Tricksters, he drops Howling Mine and Jace. I correctly figure he's playing Jacerator. I wait for him to tap most of his mana for a Font of Mythos, then I untap, cast Telemin Performance, and kill him in a single blow. Booyah.

Game 2 he drops an early Wall of Denial (Better than Baneslayer against Telemin). He drops Jace as well, and ramps it up. I play Telemin Performance, which gets Negated. He drops a Font, and I drop a Telemin Performance. He mills me for 20, but unfortunately he has less cards than me now and no answer in his deck. He loses the game to mill.

1-3 (Random win! Woot!)

And that ends Blisters On Your Fingers. Join me next time I get a post up (which might not be until Sunday, but hopefully is before that) for the results of It's A Wonderful Life!

See ya!


Friday, August 21, 2009

Why You Guys Were Right: Situational Cards vs. Topdeck Cards

Yesterday, I held a comments poll over what card was better: Mind Control or Sleep? The situation was Pack One, Pick One of a draft.

When the results were in, Mind Control won 3-0. All three commentors gave good reasons. Here are their comments:

AndreStompy: Mind Control. I find it's just better. That's not to discount Sleep, which is quite a good card. But I feel much more comfortable picking Mind Control knowing I'll play it, than if I were to pick Sleep and have to only be so-so in this deck.

Basically, Mind Control is only a dead draw if they don't have creatures, in which case, who cares about a dead draw?

Mtgcolorpie: Mind Control. Your bomb has now become my bomb. Sleep is more situational if you could finish them off or need to hold them off. Everyone plays creatures in limited.



Thomas David Baker: Mind Control.

I think of Mind Control in terms of card advantage. Mind Control is simultaneously a very strong removal spell and a bomb/strong creature in one card. A really good 2-for-1. The only situation where it isn't brilliant is at less than five mana, or where you are winning anyway. In which case you now have insurance against that changing.

Sleep can win you the game, no doubt, even steal it. But it is much more situational. Mind Control is the better top deck.

The one mana difference in casting cost is not significant as you won't be casting Sleep immediately after making your fourth land drop anyway.

Thanks for all your comments, guys. All of you are correct. Let's look at the points raised here:

  • Mind Control is better than Sleep
  • Mind Control goes into a wider variety of decks
  • Mind Control performs at full power in every blue deck
  • Mind Control can take their bomb
  • Mind Control is card advantage: A Terminate and a bomb in one card (Great way of looking at it!)
  • Sleep is more situational. Mind Control is a better topdeck.
  • The one mana doesn't matter since you don't want to play Sleep Turn 4.
These are excellent points, including some that I didn't consider in my own assessment. For the record: here's my assessment:

Mind Control. Mind Control can perform a wider variety of roles than Sleep can. Sleep breaks a creature stall, and that's all it does. Stealing your opponent's best guy will 90% of the time break a creature stall. So for one more mana, you get something that does everything Sleep does, and far, far more.

The main argument I want to showcase is:

  • Sleep is more situational. Mind Control is a better topdeck card.
Thank you Thomas David Baker. You have made the exact point this article was to open with: if you could topdeck a bomb it would almost always be Mind Control, because in 99% of situations, it's more useful. However, Mind Control is a better card than Sleep in general, so let's look at some more closely matched cards.


If these cards were in the same set, available in a draft for an R/G deck, which would you pick? Personally, I would pick the Rannet, because it's more useful in some situations: like when you have 2-4 mana, for example. Ridge Rannet is almost never a totally dead draw.

The main reason Mind Control is better than Sleep is because it is almost always the better topdeck. As previously indicated, Sleep is only good in one situation, Mind Control is good in a multitude.

Until next time, may your first-pick be a bomb whenever you draw it.

P.S: Damn you guys are awesome. Seriously, I love my readership. You are all smart, totally brilliant people and I hope you keep making insightful comments for years to come. This is why I blog (that and I have too much Magic enthusiasm to keep it bottled up!) Great job, guys!

Wednesday, August 19, 2009

What If: There Was No Such Thing As Blue?

Greetings, readers. I've decided to take a break from serious posts about PTQ's and catching up on Magic to write a more whimsical post. I hope you like it. If you do, leave feedback in the comments. Positive feedback = I'll do it again.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

What if there was no such thing as blue? There are five colors in Magic, and these colors make up the color pie. So what would happen if one of them was eliminated?

Card draw, counterspells, flying and flash are all a big part of the game, so we can't just get rid of them entirely. We'd need to give them to the other colors. So without further ado, let's move into the fictional Zendikar previews, but without blue in the midst...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Welcome to Zendikar Preview Week on mtgsalivanth.blogspot.com! We've already shown you Kicker, Trap and Landfall on the site, so let's have a look at some more generic cards.

Our first card is one you've all seen before, so let's show you it before we get to the good stuff:


Our next card came from something we figured we needed in Red: decent card draw. Drawing two cards for four mana in M10 simply wasn't enough to let Red keep up with the other three colors. Even Green had better card draw than Red with Harmonize. So we made a card that we feel really symbolises Red's flavour: if you're willing to go all-out, you'll receive a pretty neat reward.

Check out Burning Inspiration:


This card is pretty good in Draft if you draft the right deck to make use of it, and it'll probably see play in Constructed too. Could this push Red Deck Wins into the top decks?

The next card to show you has an interesting design story. R&D wanted to make a red counterspell, since it's hardly fair for Red to miss out when everyone else gets a cut, but counterspells aren't exactly random. We tried with different variations, like "Counter target spell with an odd converted mana cost", but eventually we figured out what was wrong.

We were coming at the problem from the wrong angle. Being able to play the card was pretty random, but what we wanted were the kind of cards where when you PLAYED the spell, you didn't know what would happen. Of course, that was weak in a counterspell, so we decided to give Red a helping hand with counterspells, without quite giving it the same level as the other colors.

I think the solution we came up with is a good one. Let's give a warm welcome to Chaos Swerve.


The templating here is pretty confusing, so let me explain. A spell is only a spell while it's on the stack. Once it's off the stack, if it's not a permanent, it leaves the stack and goes to the graveyard, and if it is, it becomes that permanent type. So essentially, we have a card that counters a card half the time, but if you counter a counterspell with it, it will always counter the spell. So we have, rather unusually, an anti-counterspell counterspell: a great way of letting Red fight counterspells without giving it the same level as White or Black, the primary counterspell colors (Green, of course, only getting counterspells to protect itself and it's permanents).

The next card to show you is a multi-color card. Multicolor will only show up on a few cards in Zendikar, but the ones we have are quite good. Here, we originally had the following card:

4GW

Instant

Counter target spell. You may put X +1/+1 counters on target creature, where X was it's converted mana cost.

However, this card felt too much like Draining Specter from Time Spiral, which essentially did the same thing in mono-black.


So we decided: What if we made an 'either-or' card rather than a 'both' card?

This led to Managrowth:


Managrowth will often go one way or the other, but it can lead to good 'Magic stories' when your opponent makes the wrong choice. All in all, it's a fairly elegant design.

The next card came from a need to make mono-green a bit more powerful. Mono-green by definition has a hard time dealing with creatures, but it is the master of Flash and of Deathtouch, so when you combine them you get a strong card, as evident in Winged Coatl, the 1GW card from Alara Reborn. But it wasn't quite enough: so we decided to make a better one.

Winged Coatl 2.0 is here: Venomweb Spider.


And now it's time for the last one. We've deliberately saved the best for last: Mind Crush is certain to become one of the power cards in the set. Rather than set it up, we'll just show you this powerful counterspell:


So now you have it folks: some of the goodies from Zendikar. We've got more next week as we discuss the design of the Trap mechanic, why we brought back Kicker, and more. We'll also have a couple of preview cards for you, so be sure to tune in.

Until next time, may the answer to your problems be elegant.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Well, I certainly hope you found that interesting (and I hope I didn't butcher your writing style TOO badly MaRo, if you're reading this). Remember: if you liked this post, be sure to tell me on Twitter or via the comments, and I'll do some more every couple of weeks.

Until next time, may you explore the hypothetical.

Monday, August 3, 2009

Faeries Never Dies!

Faeries is dead. Dead as a doornail, dead as Elvis, dead as the dinosaurs. Right?

I seem to remember this stuff being said before. Oh that's right. It was after Conflux, when Volcanic Fallout came out. Of course, Great Sable Stag is in a whole new level. Faeries can still survive. But it has to change a bit. It has to give a little to get a little. And that little is a little thing called Lightning Bolt.

As Wizards probably intended, Lightning Bolt is the perfect answer to Great Sable Stag. For one mana, it kills it. And in this world where playing UUU, WW, GG and RR in the same deck is perfectly reasonable, we can pretty easily make a splash for some of Red's greatest.

Here's the list that came 5th at France's Nationals. (Two other Fae decks placed higher, but they used Time Warp, and we're going with a tried and true build here.)


Not bad, but with 3 Fae decks in the Top 8, I think that GSS is more popular in America than France. Since most of my readers are American, we need to tune it to the GSS-stuffed metagame.

Here's my proposed list:

Next Level Faeries:

4 Lightning Bolt
3 Terminate

Legendary Creatures
2
Vendilion Clique

Planeswalkers
2
Jace Beleren

Tribal Enchantments
4
Bitterblossom

Basic Lands
2
Island
2
Swamp
1 Mountain

Lands

3 Cascade Bluffs
4 Crumbling Necropolis
4 Drowned Catacomb
1
Mutavault
4 Secluded Glen
4
Sunken Ruins

Sideboard:
2
Puppeteer Clique
4 Anathemancer
3 Glen Elendra Archmage
3
Flashfreeze
3 Double Negative

I haven't actually tested this list yet, but I intend to once Magic Workstation decides to be nice. Sometime in the next few days I'll post a report of the testing. I'm sure I'll come into direct contact with Great Sable Stags. In the meantime, feel free to test and adjust the decklist yourselves. The sideboard of this deck is tuned towards Jund and Five-Color decks specifically, since they'll show up in big numbers at PTQ's and other events, which is what this list is aimed towards. I hope it does well for you.

I like Faeries. I think it has it's place in the metagame. It's a good foil to Five-Color, which has now risen to dominance. Hopefully this can bring it back as a Tier 1 strategy.

Until next time, may what you thought was dead rise from the grave.

Lessons I've Learnt Today:

I intend to make this a regular posting whenever I learn something about Magic, so I can share it with all of you. Some of these lessons aren't from today, but I'm catching up.

Never, ever, play Cruel if you even think the opponent might have a possibility of having a counter. Especially if he plays 5CC better than you.

Ajani Goldmane gaining life is actually good against Blightning. Especially if you defend him with Harm's Way. Eventually, they'll run out of gas and you can play a big-ass Avatar. Or a token generator and give the tokens +1/+1 countery goodness.

Figure of Destiny is absolutely nuts against 5CC. If you're at 6 mana, you have an 8/8 in 2 turns for one card.

Goldmeadow Stalwart isn't that good in a 14 Kithkin deck. Path to Exile and HW are better draws.

See you tomorrow!